Blog / Work & society

Humans in a World of Value: Money, Skills, Algorithms, and Work That Doesn’t Cost Us Our Lives

Pakorn AJ Leesakul 7 min read
Gold and silver coins resting on banknotes
Photo: Kanchanara / Unsplash

From barter to money

Exchange did not begin with money. People once traded goods for goods — barter, or what Thais call yuen moo, yuen maew (“hand over a pig, take a cat”). But barter has two limits. First, what we have may not be what the other side wants: someone with a duck who wants rice has to find a person who has rice and happens to want a duck. Second, it is hard to agree on a fair rate of exchange. So people created “money” as a go-between that society accepts together.

Once money existed, every object came to have two kinds of value: use value and exchange value. We can eat food, but we cannot eat money. Food is used up once eaten, while money keeps circulating through the system, turning into wages, costs and profits without end.

Land is a clear example. In terms of use, land can hold a home that gives security, a mall that keeps the economy moving, or the memory of history. In terms of exchange, its price rises and falls with appraisals, markets and currency values that its owner cannot control. Use value is therefore the more stable of the two, while exchange value often leaves us on the losing side — and when the two clash, crisis tends to follow.

Money as power

The basic job of money is to be a medium of exchange, but in practice money has become power. First, people who hold more money often feel superior to those who have less. The questions we ask once we get to know each other — “What do you do?” or “How much do you earn?” — are therefore not ordinary questions. Second, money grants power over other people’s labour. An employer may hand a freelancer work that cannot be finished in a day and use higher pay as the incentive. The result is that the worker has to push themselves too hard, because money is valued more than the person.

Put another way, money stands for value and for social relationships. It is reproduced until it becomes a sign of identity, space and power. Success comes to be measured by the ability to create exchange value, so many businesses focus on stimulating short-term, trend-driven consumption rather than long-term sustainability.

Companies such as Microsoft and Google began by offering services rather than tangible products, and created so much use value that people can no longer do without them. Yet technology is often put to work for capital and short-term profit, endlessly reproducing a capitalist class. The state regulates the resources of institutions such as the military, but barely intervenes in how businesses hold money. Businesses that put use value and human survival first may therefore be the answer for the future.

Skills people need in the age of AI

As AI takes over repetitive work, the value of working people shifts to skills that machines find hard to replace. Data entry, customer service, goods inspection and administrative jobs are at risk of disappearing, while roles such as software developer, data engineer and data analyst are emerging in their place. Those who do not reskill and upskill will face a “skill gap” — a mismatch between the skills they have and the skills organisations need.

Hard skills get you the interview, but soft skills get you the job and help you keep it. These are the skills worth building:

  • Learning agility. Alvin Toffler pointed out that the illiterate of the future will be those who cannot learn, unlearn and relearn. That means asking questions, acting quickly, reflecting on yourself and daring to try new things.
  • Resilience. See negative events as chances to learn, stop seeing yourself as a victim, and practise mindfulness.
  • Grounded optimism. Look for the positive side while still counting the worst-case outcome in the equation.
  • Communication. Make sure policy changes are understood the same way by everyone, so work doesn’t get passed around, and move the organisation from pain points to touch points.
  • Storytelling. The same subject can be told in four ways: definition, narrative, story (drawn from experience) and analogy. For example, SEO can be explained as opening a restaurant: the menu is your keywords, the taste is content quality, the location is site structure, and reviews are backlinks. Which to choose depends on the audience and the goal.
  • Literacy in many dimensions. Digital literacy (understanding how technology works, such as privacy settings), media literacy (telling fact from opinion, and advertorials from genuine reviews) and data literacy (turning data into information, knowledge and wisdom) — so that we move from people who “know it all” to people who “learn it all.”

Algorithms and the echo chamber

A man holding a mobile phone up to his face
Photo: Nathana Rebouças / Unsplash

Digital technology delivers only half of the equality it promises. Children in remote areas can reach knowledge, but the systems that curate information for us carry built-in bias (algorithmic bias). Top-ranked search results get seen more. Plagiarism checkers flag students whose first language isn’t English more often. Crime-prediction systems such as PredPol send police into communities of colour more often; the more police are sent, the more “crime” they find, in an endless loop — while people who are not in the data at all are made invisible.

On social media, Facebook ranks the feed using three parts: inventory (the content available to show), signals (recency, credibility, spam) and predictions (what it expects us to like, share or hide). The result is a feed that is remarkably on point. But if we engage with one-sided or fake news, the feed fills up with it. We get stuck in a “Daily Me” and an echo chamber where we hear only what we want to hear.

This is fertile ground for conspiracy theories, which reason backwards from effect to cause — like “there’s a traffic jam, so it must have just rained” — settling on the answer first and then finding reasons to support it. People who use social media to fill gaps in their offline lives are especially vulnerable. The Cambridge Analytica case, in which user data was taken without consent and used for propaganda in the 2016 US election, shows how easily a tool for “connecting people” can become a political weapon.

Lessons from karoshi: measure results, not hours

An office worker working late at a desk in a dimly lit room
Photo: Vitaly Gariev / Unsplash

Working hard is not always the answer. Japan has a word, karoshi, meaning death from overwork. The media began using it around 1982, after many working-age people died of heart disease and stroke with no history of illness. The widely reported 2016 case of a young woman at an advertising agency, who faced both an overwhelming workload and pressure from her superiors (power harassment), forced Japan to review its labour laws once again. A culture that glorifies devotion beyond one’s limits can still be seen in the entertainment and manga industries, going back to the era of Osamu Tezuka.

The way out is an innovative culture. Innovare means a new method, and colere means to cultivate. In other words, it is not about forcing people to come up with new things all the time, but about creating space for the ideas everyone already has to come out. Practices that help include:

  1. Split goals into long, medium and short term, then prioritise by how well what the organisation, your manager and you want line up.
  2. Form a hypothesis of the end result from the start and adjust along the way, instead of gathering information endlessly.
  3. Know when B+ work in one day is worth more than A work in one week.
  4. Leave two 30-minute blocks of free time a day for reflection, get enough sleep and exercise regularly.
  5. Keep meetings to 60–90 minutes, send documents in advance, and end with an owner and a deadline.
  6. Cut out blame speech, and stop judging people’s worth by the hours they spend in the office.

Conclusion

From the days of trading a pig for a cat to feeds curated by algorithms, people are still trying to fill what is missing in themselves, just as before. What has changed are the tools — and those tools are nudging us to value everything by its exchange value: salaries, likes and working hours.

The key question, then, is not how much money we have or how much work we can do, but how much use value we create for ourselves, the people around us and society. Businesses that help people survive, skills that let us think for ourselves, and workplaces that don’t cost us our lives are three sides of the same answer.

Photo credits

  1. Gold and silver coins on banknotes: Kanchanara / Unsplash
  2. A man with a mobile phone: Nathana Rebouças / Unsplash
  3. Working late in an office: Vitaly Gariev / Unsplash

All photos are free to use under the Unsplash License.

← All posts